This is a blog about music, photography, history, and culture.
These are photographs from my collection that tell a story about lost time and forgotten music.

Mike Brubaker
{ Click on the image to expand the photo }

The March Away From War

15 November 2026

 
It was a parade of soldiers.
Soldiers who were used to marching,
but not for this kind of military review.







Only a year earlier in July 1914
these same soldiers had all marched proudly
as their countries mobilized for war. 







But this kind of parade was different
and conveyed a comfortless sentiment
with less patriotic cheering
and more spiteful jeers.







They were still soldiers
but they carried no weapons
and displayed no regimental banners.
These were men taken from many battlefields
either through surrender or capture.

Now they were marching away from war
as prisoners of their enemy.

In honor of Veterans Day,
formerly known as Armistice Day,
I present a selection of postcards
of soldiers from the Great War of 1914–1918.






My first postcard is a photo of hundreds of unarmed soldiers slowly trudging down a narrow road through a cordon of armed soldiers as a crowd of civilians look on. It is a long column of German soldiers captured sometime in the autumn of 1914. The postcard's caption reads:
La Guerre de 1914. L. C. H. Paris
Prisonniers allemands escortés par des Anglais à St-Nazaire.
German prisoners escorted by English soldiers at St-Nazaire.

Saint-Nazaire is a port city in Brittany on France's western Atlantic coast. In August 1914 it became one of the main landing ports for the British Expeditionary Force. The back of the card has a message from a French soldier, sent as an attachment to a letter. His name and unit is carefully noted in the top right. 
Lefèvre Léon, Brigadier                    
7e  d’Artillerie, 23e Batterie                    
60e Division, Secteur postal 105                    



            Le 31-12-14
                            Chères cousines,
                        Encore une année qui vient de se terminer. Je
                        vous envoie mes meilleurs vœux de bonne année.
                        Je me porte à merveille et je désire que vous
                        soyez en excellente santé. En ce moment il
                        gèle,
mot c'est un temps excellent pour nous.
                        À bientôt, chères cousines. Votre cousin qui
                        vous aime et vous embrasse de loin.
                                                                Léon
~
                    31 December 1914
                                Dear cousins,
                            Another year has just come to an end. I
                            end you my best wishes for a happy new year.
                            I am doing marvelously, and I hope you
                            are in excellent health. At the moment it is
                            freezing, and it is excellent weather for us.
                            See you soon, dear cousins. Your cousin, who
                            loves you and kisses you from afar.
                                                                                Léon


Leon was a brigadier, the equivalent of a corporal, in a French artillery battery. This was the basic unit of an artillery regiment which might fire either mobile field guns or fixed heavy guns. During World War I a French artillery regiment typically comprised 9 to 12 batteries organized into 3 to 4 groups with four cannon in each battery. The age of motorized armies was still decades away in the future, so all units in every army depended on horse drawn wagons to haul equipment, munitions, food, and supplies. 

A single cannon required six horses to pull its carriage and another six to pull its ammunition box. Each battery of four cannon would typically have three officers, 170 non-commissioned officers and enlisted men, and 170 horses to pull the cannon and other equipment wagons. A full artillery  regiment might require 1,500 horses to move its guns onto the battlefield.  

Presentation of a 75 mm model 1897 cannon and its ammunition box
by French artillerymen (in midnight blue uniform) to Scottish infantry officers (in khaki), on the sidelines of the Battle of Armentières on October 21, 1914.
Source: Wikipedia


According to Wikipedia:
During World War I, the French artillery expanded significantly, growing from 434,000 personnel in August 1914 (16% of the total army) to 771,000 by 1918 (26% of the total), excluding logistical units tasked with ammunition transport.





My second photo postcard is another parade of a long column of unarmed soldiers escorted between a close cordon of other soldiers who carry bayoneted rifles. They are turning a corner of a brick-paved city street. Buildings in the background show severe damage from bombardment. The guards are German soldiers wearing Pickelhaube helmets with its characteristic pointed finial. Their prisoners are mainly French soldiers wearing the Adrian helmet with its distinctive crest which was designed to deflect shrapnel. This steel headgear was made in 1915 as a replacement for the French army's standard kepi cap which being made of red cloth provided no protection against battlefield gunfire and shelling. The 1915 change in uniform also included discarding the French infantry's traditional red pantaloons, too.  

The other captured men are Scottish soldiers dressed in kilts and wearing khaki Tam o’Shanters. This headgear was a also replacement, made by the British military to supplant the dark-blue Glengarry bonnet worn by the Scots when Britain first mobilized its troops in August 1914.    

I featured this photo postcard once before in The Color of War which I posted on 12 November 2022, also in honor of Veterans Day. But for that story I didn't include the back of the card. It has a simple annotation, a remembrance really,  which identifies the location.


                                        Gefangenen Einbringung
                                        in Lille bei der letzten Schlacht.
                                            Oktober 1915
~             
                                       Bringing in prisoners
                                        in Lille after the final battle.
                                        October 1915.


Lille is a city in the northern part of France, within French Flanders on the border with Belgium. It was captured by the German army in October 1914 after a ten-day siege that bombarded the city with heavy artillery resulting in the destruction of 882 apartment/office blocks and 1,500 residential houses, mostly around the central railway station.

The city was occupied by the German army which used its strategic location on the Western Front as the main command center and central hub for transport of troops and material. It remained in German control until it was liberated by the Allies on 17 October 1918. 

The "final battle" referenced in the note is likely the Battle of Loos which was fought  from 25 September to 8 October 1915. It was part of a larger major campaign by French and British forces to attack and break German defenses in Flanders. This battle marked the first use of chemical weapons by the British. Hundreds of canisters of chlorine gas were deployed along their front line to force German troops into the open. For various reasons this tactic failed and the Germans successfully defended their territory. Over the two weeks of battle the British suffered 59,247 casualties, many due to misjudging where the wind would blow their chlorine gas. The Germans sustained losses of around  26,000 soldiers.




This postcard shows another column of German soldiers striding along a dirt track while being escorted by mounted French colonial troops from north Africa. The printed caption reads:
174. La Grande Guerre 1914 – Goumiers ramenant
des prisonniers Allemands de Dixmude à Furnes. J. M. T.
~
No. 174. The Great War 1914 – Goumiers bringing
back German prisoner from Dixmude to Furnes.

Dixmude (Diksmuide) and Furnes (Veurne) are cities in Belgium's Flemish province of West Flanders. 

The term Goumiers refers to indigenous Moroccan soldiers who served in auxiliary units attached to the French Army of Africa. However this card's caption is mislabeled because during WW1 Moroccan irregular troops were not used in Europe. In this picture the riders dressed in long wool cloaks and turbans are called Spahi, a light-cavalry unit recruited for the French army primarily from the Arab and Berber populations of Algeria, Tunisia, and Morocco, too. At the beginning of the war when battles were more mobile the mounted Spahi cavalry served in small detachments mainly as scouts, skirmishers and escorts. Here they take German prisoners away from the front to be transported to special camps.

Both Britain and France had a great advantage over Germany with their respective colonial empires which provided many extra troops, laborers, and material for the allied war effort. However the cost of bringing these foreign soldiers to Europe was hugely expensive and placed them in great danger of German submarine attacks while troops were transported in ships. During the war many allied colonial soldiers from north Africa, India, Africa, Canada, Australia, and New Zealand were captured and sent to German POW camps. 


The back of the card has a message which was sent in a letter packet.



                        Le 2-1-17
                                       Ma chère petite Germaine,
                                    Nous te remercions tous de ton aimable lettre et 
                                    des vœux que tu formes pour nous tous. 
                                    Nous sommes tous en bonne santé, mais. 
                                    Depuis hier nous avons une légère couche 
                                    de neige, il fait froid. 
                                    Nous avons quelques soldats du pays en 
                                    permission.
                                    Tu embrasseras pour moi papa et maman.
                                    La petite amie qui t'envoie un gros baiser,
                                                            [?]avie Veyre
~
                               2 January 1917
                                            My dear little Germaine,
                                        We all thank you for your kind letter and 
                                        for the good wishes you offer for all of us. 
                                        We are all in good health. 
                                        Since yesterday we have had a light layer 
                                        of snow, and it is cold. 
                                        We have a few soldiers from the area home 
                                        on leave.
                                        Give Papa and Mama a kiss for me.
                                        Your little friend, who sends you a big kiss,
                                                                                [?]avie Veyre

This note was written by a civilian, I believe, and not a soldier. I'm unsure if the writer was a man or woman as the first letters in the signature are a style I can't decipher. Even my A.I. assistant Claude, who helps me with translations, had trouble with it, proposing “Flavie,” “Marie” or something similar. 





This postcard photo shows a smaller group of prisoners, maybe around a hundred men, as they walk along a dirt road. In the background I think I see hints of a railway crossing, so these men may be new arrivals at a prisoner of war camp. Many of the men are clearly wounded with soldiers swathed in bandages and walking with canes. The caption reads: 
12.  Verwundete Franzosen
~
No. 12.   Wounded Frenchmen 

These are French prisoners who have survived a battle but now walk towards an unknown future. Because they wear kepi hats and pantaloons this photo dates from 1914 or early 1915. 

The back has a German stamp and an unclear postmark, possibly from Weinhiem, in northwest Baden-Württemberg, Germany. The date is maybe 29-0?-14. It was sent to a Fraulein in Tecklenburg, a town in North Rhine-Westphalia. I hope the young woman could read the scribbled pencil message as Claude gave up. 




In August 1914 the belligerent nations of Europe that mobilized for war were each convinced that their cause was just. Each government rallied its citizens to a patriotic purpose and mustered soldiers determined to fight for their country. Within weeks long lines of battle cut across vast regions of eastern and western Europe. In the beginning it was all mobile warfare, but really only at the speed of men and horses.  Trains were confined to railway networks. Motorized vehicles were still too underpowered for military use. Airplanes and airships were likewise limited in power and severely curtailed by bad weather conditions. Generals knew that success in battle would be determined by boot leather and horseshoes as much as by rifles and artillery.  

As early as September 1914, German forces had already captured roughly 125,050 French soldiers and 94,000 Russian soldiers. Over the course of the war, Russia would capture roughly 2.1 million Austro-Hungarian troops, with massive numbers surrendered during the chaotic autumn and winter campaigns of 1914. By the end of the war in November 1918 an estimated 7–9 million soldiers from nations all around the world  were held in prisoner-of-war camps. Roughly 10% (~750,000) died in captivity.   

These postcards of captured soldiers that I've presented here were a type of propaganda, though I can't say they were officially produced by any government agency. They depict a defeated enemy escorted by resolute soldiers of the home guard. In an age when there was no radio and no television, these postcard photos told a story of warfare that was meant to convey a positive outlook for each nation's war effort. Each country wanted victorious pictures like these to distract the public from horrible reports of death and destruction. Seeing countless unarmed soldiers being removed from battlelines surely encouraged some people to hope that the war would soon end. 

Of course the great tragedy is that it didn't. As the war was prolonged the scale of military casualties and civilian deaths only increased, finally becoming monstrous numbers beyond our comprehension. Even now, over a century later, the consequences of the First World War still divide many nations. These postcards serve as a remembrance of what the world lost. 

  




This is my contribution to Sepia Saturday
where the word on the street
is that old photos never get dull.




nolitbx

  © Blogger template Shush by Ourblogtemplates.com 2009

Back to TOP