For reasons I can not explain
some vintage photo portraits of musicians,
almost always cornet players,
include an important but often ignored
musical accessory—the folding music stand.
almost always cornet players,
include an important but often ignored
musical accessory—the folding music stand.
The stands are simple metal contraptions
that add no decorative quality to the photo setting
that add no decorative quality to the photo setting
and only serve a practical purpose
to hold a musician's sheet music.
to hold a musician's sheet music.
The design of these music stands has changed very little
since they were first introduced in the 19th century.
since they were first introduced in the 19th century.
They are light weight, compact, portable and place
the music at a comfortable reading position
for players of any height.
the music at a comfortable reading position
for players of any height.
The odd thing is,
that with rare exception,
(A Tuba Player from Lowville, New York)
it is cornet players who chose
that with rare exception,
(A Tuba Player from Lowville, New York)
it is cornet players who chose
to have a folding music stand in the photo.
I don't know why.
A slender metal music stand was
an unremarkable photographic prop.
It always came with sheet music,
sometimes clearly visible,
that emphasized or enhanced a musical quality
that was unstated but apparently once understood by viewers.
Trombone players didn't need one in their portrait.
Likewise clarinetists, violinists, and drummers had their picture taken
without including a common music stand in the scene.
Yet many cornet players felt it was important
to have one in their portrait.
to have one in their portrait.
Again, I don't know why.
So today I present a small representation of anonymous cornetists
who demonstrated they could read music.
who demonstrated they could read music.
My first example is a cabinet card photo of a serious looking cornet player dressed in a fine bandsman's uniform and cap. He is unidentified but the photographer was Smith, of Eau Claire, Wisconsin, a city at the confluence of the Eau Claire and Chippewa Rivers, 100 miles east of Minneapolis, Minnesota. On the player's right is a folding music stand with an open folio of music. The camera has "almost" caught the dots in focus.
The two pages have printed parts to four different compositions. The small size of each part remains the standard for band music even today. When pinned to an instrument's music lyre the part is about 12 inches from a player's nose. Only a few instruments lack an attachment bracket for a lyre. Snare drummers have one on the drum rim and bass drums on the body of the drum. But cymbal players have to memorize their parts. Flute and piccolo players have no room on their instruments for a music lyre and the instruments point toward the player's right side. Instead they use either a long stick with a lyre on it that is clutched under the player's armpit, or a lyre fixed to a wrist band. Pieces of flute and piccolo can sometimes litter a football field after a strenuous marching choreography of a halftime show.
A second Eau Claire cornetist also had his portrait taken with the same music stand. He is younger than the other man and clean shaven but wears the same style uniform and cap. His cabinet card is marked from Smith & Donaldson of 102 & 104 Kelsey St. in Eau Claire, Wisconsin. The young man must have paid extra for a premium photo mount as, unlike his companion's photo, his card comes with a very beautiful imprint on the back for the Riverside Art Studio of Smith and Donaldson. Notice the Grecian-Wisconsin maiden is holding a paintbrush and small card (photo?) as she contemplates an idyllic view of the river.
Eau Claire's name is derived from the original French name, "Eaux Claires", meaning "Clear Waters". The city was first incorporated in 1872 when its population was around 2,300. By 1890 it could boast of 17,415 citizens. The partnership of photographers Frank A. Smith and D. W. Donaldson began in June 1887. But in August 1889 they broke up with Smith continuing the business. That would make these two photos with the double names of Smith & Donaldson and the single name Smith, to date from the summer of 1889. This Wisconsin region had several bands including an Eau Claire Cornet Band, but without clear uniform insignia or other clues to their identification these two cornet players can't be connected to a specific band.
One last curiosity is the music on the stand. The parts are the same but in the second photo there is a pipe-like thing propped next to the music. At first I thought it was a penny whistle or fife, but it is actually an extra leadpipe for the cornet with its mouthpiece at the bottom. In this era cornets could use another leadpipe to shorten or lengthen the instrument and play in other keys. Why this player thought to add it to the photo is a mystery. Maybe just showing off.
* * *
This next cabinet card portrait shows both the cornet player and his music stand in full view. He sports an impressive brush mustache and wears a formal suit and black bowtie. His concentration on the music makes him appear about ready to play. The photograph was taken at the studio of Hooton & Aukland of Shelby, Iowa. Unfortunately I've been unable to find any records of these photographers.
Situated in west central Iowa, Shelby is in both Pottawattamie and Shelby counties. It was first platted in 1870 during the great era of America's western railroad expansion and its population in 1870 was around 300. By 1890, which is about when this photograph was taken, it had grown to only 582 and has stayed about the same for the past century. However the big city of Omaha, Nebraska is only 35 miles to the southwest, so I think it likely that both the photographers and the cornet player were only passing through Shelby. The musician's fine formal suit suggests he was a professional entertainer, maybe a member of a vaudeville troupe rather than a band. The position of his music stand also implies his performance is of soloist quality.
* * *
This next cabinet card photo shows a bandsman dressed in a uniform similar to the two fellows from Eau Claire. It's another full length portrait of both man and his music stand that appears to have them floating in the air as the floor and backdrop are all white. His instrument is technically not a cornet even though it has a similar shape. I'm not entirely sure what it is, but it could be a kind of bass trumpet or a variation of a flugelhorn. In either case it is much longer than a B-flat cornet but not quite as long as a valve trombone. I have other examples of the instrument and I just call it the big cornet.
* * *
My last photo of a cornetist with his music stand is a serious young man with blond hair and mustache looking directly at the camera. He is dressed in fine suit with pinstriped trousers. His collar is not a clerical collar but has a tie concealed by his coat. He looks German or Nordic to me. Unfortunately there is a glare on his instrument that covers any fancy engraving and likewise his music is bleached out. Nonetheless I think it is a fine portrait.
The photographers were Lowry & Towner of Helena, Montana. Helena was a city literally built on gold as the result of a discovery of gold deposits there in July 1864. According to Helena's Wikipedia entry, "By 1888 about 50 millionaires lived in Helena, more per capita than in any city in the world. They had made their fortunes from gold. It is estimated about $3.6 billion in today's money was extracted from Helena during this period of time. The Last Chance Placer is one of the most famous placer deposits in the western United States. Most of the production occurred before 1868. Much of the placer is now under Helena's streets and buildings."
The two photographers Lowry and Towner seemed to have started operation in June 1888 and by the following summer of 1889 were gone. Helena also had a German language newspaper, Die Montana German Press and Montana Staats-Zeitung so it's possible that he was a German musician. His suit also reflects wealth more than the wild west. However I don't see him wearing a cowboy hat.
This is my contribution to Sepia Saturday
where some people are rather proud of their favorite chair.